Player Ratings?

[TwentySeven]

I am just wondering what level of player corresponds to the create-a-player one-to-five star ratings.

I think that it corresponds as follows:

five stars - perrenial all star, possibly a future hall of famer

four stars- solid starter for most teams, might be an all star a few years, but not exactly a hall of famer

three stars - starter for a low level team or bench player for one of the better teams

two stars - utility/bench player for a lower level team, but for higher level teams might end up an injury replacement or AAA player

one star - career minor leaguer

how does it actually correspond?

[Frappy]

I think your Gap from five to four is too big.

Five- Accurate

Four- I would say perrenial all-star "challenger" with Solid to very good all-around skill.

Three- Solid player and/or player strong in one area of the game but lacking in others. Would be a starter for most teams. CAN STILL have very good numbers.

Two- Average player who'd have to compete for a starting role. Serviceable, but nothing great.

One-Not a career minor leaguer, can still crack the MLB team. Depends on starting skills.

Take note Im assuming you're talking about what they'd eventually be in their prime because the star ratings are for potential.