Jump to content

MVP07 or MVP08?


Cavicchi

Do you prefer MVP 07 or MVP 08 or MVP2005?  

76 members have voted

  1. 1.

    • 3. MVP 2005 (original game).
      9
    • 1. MVP 07
      17
    • 2. MVP 08
      49
    • 4. none of the above
      1


Recommended Posts

Since I noticed MVP07 is the number one download as of this writing, I can't help but wonder if many have found MVP07 a better choice and why? Do you prefer MVP07 or MVP08?

I know MVP08 is not available on this site, but I still think this is a valid question.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 70
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Since I noticed MVP07 is the number one download as of this writing, I can't help but wonder if many have found MVP07 a better choice and why? Do you prefer MVP07 or MVP08?

I know MVP08 is not available on this site, but I still think this is a valid question.

Easy question to answer, at least I think so. Try them both. I have both 07 and 08 installed on mine. On the 08 mod there will be a patch that is supposed to be released in the near future and it will update some stuff on it. (What is supposed to be updated is something I don't know.)

Both mods are good. You can't go wrong on either one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since I noticed MVP07 is the number one download as of this writing, I can't help but wonder if many have found MVP07 a better choice and why? Do you prefer MVP07 or MVP08?

I know MVP08 is not available on this site, but I still think this is a valid question.

I think 08 is far better than 07

Not that 07 wasn't good

And 07 is only the number one download because it's been downloaded more than 08, but 07 has been out for much longer than 08

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think 08 is far better than 07

Not that 07 wasn't good

And 07 is only the number one download because it's been downloaded more than 08, but 07 has been out for much longer than 08

Well, I can't say 08 is far better than 07, and I am not sure it is any better.

1. The crowd noise in 08 is a continous loud noise that is so annoying I have to turn it off. In 07 the crowd noise was interesting with comments from the crowd--and I had no reason to turn it off.

2. What is the point of having a pitch meter when there is no green?

3. Camera views are a tossup, not sure which I like better at this time, and same goes for the overlay.

4. The change in terminology for things like "Starting 9" and GM, etc. is another tossup, and I don't know why that was changed--what needs to be changed is the dialogue from announcers.

5. Overall, I just don't see where 08 is better than 07 at this time. There are some things 07 does better than 08.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I can't say 08 is far better than 07, and I am not sure it is any better.

1. The crowd noise in 08 is a continous loud noise that is so annoying I have to turn it off. In 07 the crowd noise was interesting with comments from the crowd--and I had no reason to turn it off.

2. What is the point of having a pitch meter when there is no green?

3. Camera views are a tossup, not sure which I like better at this time, and same goes for the overlay.

4. The change in terminology for things like "Starting 9" and GM, etc. is another tossup, and I don't know why that was changed--what needs to be changed is the dialogue from announcers.

5. Overall, I just don't see where 08 is better than 07 at this time. There are some things 07 does better than 08.

You can always turn the crown noise down a notch.

I agree with the pitch meter. Having to edit the datafile, or insert another one is not good. Who knows what other stuff is then missing.

I like the camera view, went back to the ESPN 3.1 overlay however.

Yes, the terminology, like "What are you? A quitter?" seen every time is annoying.

And worst of all, who came up with the idea of changing the folder in My Documents to EAMods' MVP 08. Really bad idea. I don't like changes being made to my machine without advance notice. In addition, all of my sliders for all the other games, '56, '88, and '61 were wiped out. Luckily I had backups.

Anyway, I've gone back to 07. Too many changes and not for the better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. In 07 the crowd noise was interesting with comments from the crowd--and I had no reason to turn it off.

My favorite was "Alou, you stink."

It completely caught me off guard the first time I heard it, and it was still very funny every other time I heard it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My favorite was "Alou, you stink."

It completely caught me off guard the first time I heard it, and it was still very funny every other time I heard it.

Yes, there are a bunch of humorous shouts from the crowd--all seem to be missing in MVP08.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not true about the humor shouts. You stink is heard in various stadiums seeminly programmed toward certain players and/or batting slots.

I will agree with the cutesy changes to some of the wording. The novelty has worn off. But not a game breaker.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it too late to start a poll?

It can be:

1. MVP08 kicks a**

2. MVP07 is still the best

3. MVP06 righfully owns

4. MVP05 is where it's at

5. Where is MVP09?

Or you can also have one for which Total Conversion Kicks a**. :lol: @ (5)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it too late to start a poll?

It can be:

1. MVP08 kicks a**

2. MVP07 is still the best

3. MVP06 righfully owns

4. MVP05 is where it's at

5. Where is MVP09?

Or you can also have one for which Total Conversion Kicks a**. :lol: @ (5)

Sounds good to me. Since you put it so well, why don't you start the poll?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why don't you contact the author and ask for a refund, then?

Oh, wait...

Why don't you keep your smart mouth to yourself? I purchased the game, but lost the 2nd disc a long time ago. Most mods come with NO CD cracks. This one, for some unknown reason, doesn't. It'd have been nice to know that before spending part of my day off installing a mod that can't be played without a 4 year old disc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you had bothered to take any time whatsoever looking around, you would've already known that it didn't. it's a pretty well known and common fact for this game. don't blame others for your own stupidity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you had bothered to take any time whatsoever looking around, you would've already known that it didn't. it's a pretty well known and common fact for this game. don't blame others for your own stupidity.

Wow. Thanks for the "help" guys. You're right, I'm crazy to have assumed that there would be a no cd crack for YEARS old software that can't be bought in stores anymore. What on earth was I thinking?

Again, thanks so much for your helpful assistance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, maybe you should worry about taking better care of items you've purchased instead of losing them, especially rare games that now sell for 2 or 3 times their original purchase price on eBay, and don't worry about what I'm doing. Sound good?

If you want a no-CD crack that works with '08 so badly, if there isn't one already, go make one. I use the CDs, so I'm not sure if there is already one that exists that works with '08, but if there is, you won't find a link to it here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow. Thanks for the "help" guys. You're right, I'm crazy to have assumed that there would be a no cd crack for YEARS old software that can't be bought in stores anymore. What on earth was I thinking?

Again, thanks so much for your helpful assistance.

What is it they say about assuming, again?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...