Jump to content

Ultimate Roster Project (PC,Xbox,PS2)


llcmac

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 17.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Totte

I don't understand how do you calculate the fielding percentage of a player. Per example: David Eckstein is better than Alex gonzalez in all aspects concernig to fielding, but in the last update Alex González appears with an icon glove, but David Eckstein not.

I would appreciate any information concerning to this.

Thanks.

Sorry, i don't know if this is right post

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Totte

I don't understand how do you calculate the fielding percentage of a player. Per example: David Eckstein is better than Alex gonzalez in all aspects concernig to fielding, but in the last update Alex González appears with an icon glove, but David Eckstein not.

I would appreciate any information concerning to this.

Thanks.

Sorry, i don't know if this is right post

Totte doesn't look at only one season. he's making this kinda adjustments from a span of i think 3 years. he'll redo all ratings after this season

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Totte, those "scouting reports" found on page 745 are actually fake. They're from a kind of fantasy league that people do. Here's some more examples of these:

http://www.chronyc.com/otwb/2007/p3761.html

http://www.chronyc.com/otwb/2007/p2941.html

http://bdsl.allsimbaseball.com/lgreports/p3306.html

There's a lot of sites like that, including the Major Baseball League, where he got those reports from. If you notice, the dates are always in 2008 or beyond. While they can sometimes be used to get accurate info, most of them are just made up for the fantasy league. I recently saw one for Scott Elbert that said he threw a splitter and curveball, which is false.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Totte doesn't look at only one season. he's making this kinda adjustments from a span of i think 3 years. he'll redo all ratings after this season

If it is using an average of 3 season or more, David Eckstein is better in all the defensive aspects than Alex Gonzalez

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Totte, those "scouting reports" found on page 745 are actually fake. They're from a kind of fantasy league that people do. Here's some more examples of these:

http://www.chronyc.com/otwb/2007/p3761.html

http://www.chronyc.com/otwb/2007/p2941.html

http://bdsl.allsimbaseball.com/lgreports/p3306.html

There's a lot of sites like that, including the Major Baseball League, where he got those reports from. If you notice, the dates are always in 2008 or beyond. While they can sometimes be used to get accurate info, most of them are just made up for the fantasy league. I recently saw one for Scott Elbert that said he threw a splitter and curveball, which is false.

i did not know they were fake sorry hope i didn't mess you up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Oakland A's have claimed SP Jerome Williams off waivers from the Cubs

Cincy Reds acquired SP Sun-Woo Kim from the Rockies for future considerations

Boston received C George Kottaras from San Diego as the player to be named in the David Wells deal

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He's only 24 but he hasn't shown much yet. I can't imagine a move to the American League will help him much. Doesn't hurt to try him out, though.

A's will probably use him as a reliever.

I've increased Eckstein's fielding ratings.

Unless something unexpected occurs, UR 7.5 will be out tomorrow as scheduled

Niice, can't wait man !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Oakland A's have claimed SP Jerome Williams off waivers from the Cubs

Cincy Reds acquired SP Sun-Woo Kim from the Rockies for future considerations

Boston received C George Kottaras from San Diego as the player to be named in the David Wells deal

Thanks dude!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If it is using an average of 3 season or more, David Eckstein is better in all the defensive aspects than Alex Gonzalez

Well, I think that the best shortstop in all of baseball is Adam Everett. Article from sportingnews.com (requires membership to see the article, so i'm posting it here.)

Craig Biggio has played with dozens of shortstops in a Hall of Fame-worthy career, but the Astros second baseman doesn't hesitate when asked about Adam Everett.

"I've been here for 20 years," Biggio says, "and he's the best I've ever played with."

Anecdotal evidence is one thing. Praise from a revered teammate is great to have. But what about quantifiable data?

Thanks to The Fielding Bible, a new treatise from John Dewan on the defensive merits of major league players and teams, we have just that.

Perhaps Astros fans should pipe down about the club's inability to push through a proposed trade that would have sent Everett and Roy Oswalt to the Orioles for the big bat of Miguel Tejada at the nonwaiver trading deadline.

They should read a four-page essay from the esteemed Bill James detailing the ways in which Everett is superior to Derek Jeter and how Everett easily was the best at the position the past three seasons.

Dewan's sleep-deprived crew at Baseball Info Solutions came to that conclusion after watching video of every game played in that span and charting the direction, distance, type and result of every ball put in play.

The resulting plus-minus system, in which every fielder (catchers excluded) was assigned a rating based on how he fared against an average defender at his position, greatly advanced the cause of defensive sabermetrics.

Everett was assigned a plus-76 for the past three years, well ahead of the Pirates' Jack Wilson (plus-50), who was ranked second. Tejada, at plus-15, ranked 11th. Jeter (minus-64) was 30th, and Rangers All-Star Michael Young (minus-73) ranked 31st and last.

Asked about being the poster boy for this new fielding metric, Everett shakes his head and smiles.

"It's like, wow!" he says. "To get noticed makes you feel good. I read a little bit of the book, but I try not to get too much into that. They said they watched a ton of games the last three years, so that's pretty impressive."

So is Everett's glove, which remains strong by any measure. This year his .993 fielding percentage ranks second among shortstops -- the Giants' Omar Vizquel's ranks first -- and Everett's four errors were right behind Vizquel's three for fewest among regular shortstops.

Being sure-handed is important, but what separates Everett is his range, the way he makes the difficult play look easy and the stunning frequency with which he turns batted balls into outs.

"All I know is that defensively he's superb," Biggio says. "He saves your pitching staff with the amount of balls he can get to. . . . I just think certain guys see the ball differently off the bat. Ozzie Smith saw the ball. As you were swinging he was already breaking to the ball. There are certain guys that see the game a different way, and that's what makes them great."

Yet how many baseball observers think of Everett in those terms? Even The Fielding Bible has a diving Tejada on its cover.

That's why Dewan's plus-minus system, if it takes hold, could be a tremendous breakthrough in a long-mysterious area. Does Everett see himself at the vanguard of such a movement?

"Maybe," he says. "It just depends on how technical it gets. There's so many numbers in today's game, people lose sight of wins and losses. Ultimately, that's what it's all about."

Still, statisticians abhor vacuums every bit as much as nature does, so you can bet they'll continue tweaking the formula for measuring defense.

"They've got a stat for just about everything offensively and pitchingwise," Everett says. "I'm sure they'll have one for everything defensively here pretty soon."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...