i know a lot of you will just bash me for this, but............ you can't compare baseball players who played in the 1990s to the one of 1920s, 1930s, 40s, and on. The game changed way too much starting from the 70s and 80s. You can't really make a list of the 25 man all time list. I would say that their should be two different list, the 25 man all time list from 1890 - 1960 or 70, and another the other list staring from the 1970 or 80 - present. The games was way too different in the 20s, and 30s, compared to the 80s and 90s. Pitchers threw harder, there was a different variety of pitches at those time, and so on. So to me there can't be a 25 man all time list, it should be split into two separate era.