I'm right with you on that one. I'm lucky enough to be a Brewers fan, and I get to watch Braun play every day. He's been absolutely incredible with the bat so far, and I think my ratings do his justice for now. He's been raking for 2 months now, but I think that's too small a sample size to make his hitting ratings among the best in the league. If he finishes strong, he'll almost certainly get a big boost after the season's over.
Penny has a splitter in my roster. Thanks for your input on Braun and Penny, I appreciate it. Keep it coming!
Consider it done.
I've been doing this roster thing for awhile now, so I have a pretty good idea of what numbers will produce what rating the game gives the player. highlight_reel has a fantastic CAP tutorial over at The Sports Lodge; I suggest you check that out. It goes into extreme detail about how to rate players based on their stats.