I like it.
IMO, your opinion should be the only one that matters. If you like it, who cares what others think? I've made quite a few sigs just for the fun of it. If I really like them, I'll keep them for a while. If I don't, I get rid of them.
A month ago?!?
Seeing that it was during the holiday season, they may have been overlooked. If he asked again instead going on a ridiculous rant, he may have gotten one.