34 wins in 2 seasons
and you gave up 3 players
Brad Halsey 13-16 since trade (no longer a starter)
Dioner Navarro .245 since trade, .227 last season (horrible backup catcher)
Javier Vazquez is was not all that young (28) and you had only had him for one season. But he is 37-35 in the 3 seasons since the trade
Don't for get you got 4 players in return for Randy when you traded him away. 3 of which are still in the minors and Luis Vizcaino who did good enough to be a Type B Free Agent that Cashman let walk. now you will get a 2nd round pick and a sandwich pick because Vizcaino walked